top of page

The Market Is Not The Economy

Nov 5
3 min read

On one of these crisp autumn mornings we’re enjoying at the moment, a man takes his dog for a walk through the local park. As they both set off from the park gate, he takes the dog off its lead.


Now, although said dog is well trained at home - it becomes a lunatic in the park.


While the owner strolls along at his own pace, the dog runs amok - chasing birds, sniffing trees, running in whatever direction takes its fancy. Sometimes it is ahead of the man, sometimes behind - sometimes the dog is even facing the opposite direction to its owner.


The path the dog takes can be chaotic, all while the man trundles in the same general direction. But by the time they finish their walk together, they both end up (hopefully!) at the same point together on the other side of the park.


Dog running after latest Bank of England inflation print. Image credit: Shutterstock.
Dog running after latest Bank of England inflation print. Image credit: Shutterstock.

If you haven’t guessed already - in this analogy, the man is the economy. Strolling along at his own pace, rarely moving off the beaten path by too much - and although he stops the odd time, he is generally moving in the right direction.


Whereas the dog is the stock market - changes direction on a dime, overwhelmed by the latest thing that catches its eye. After all, all the market is day to day is just the sum of investors’ fear and greed - and our emotions can change with the wind.


At times of extreme short term dislocation, when the dog spots a squirrel for example, markets and the economy can behave in extremely different ways.

COVID was a classic of the genre, the global economy was put on ice and basically collapsed during 2020.


Source: IMF via ourworldindata.org
Source: IMF via ourworldindata.org

But stocks didn’t end up showing a loss for 2020. They showed a gain.


Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI All Country World Index in GBP (dividends reinvested).
Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI All Country World Index in GBP (dividends reinvested).

The relationship between stocks and the economy can even break down for longer periods of time. Consider the Chinese economy which has been going great guns since 2010, growing by 151%.


Source: Econorama
Source: Econorama

But during that same time period, the Chinese stock market has underperformed the growth of its economy - returning only a relatively meagre 89% in local currency terms.


Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI China Index in Chinese Renminbi (dividends reinvested).
Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI China Index in Chinese Renminbi (dividends reinvested).

Across the pond, the US economy has been chugging along at a relatively sluggish pace - only growing by 42% since 2010. Under a third of the growth rate of the Chinese economy during the same period.


Source: Econorama
Source: Econorama

But from the beginning of 2010 to the end of 2025 - the US market shot the lights out, up by a whopping 658%.


Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI USA Index in Dollars (dividends again reinvested).
Source: FE Analytics. Returns shown for the MSCI USA Index in Dollars (dividends again reinvested).

For folks who spend their days tracking the performance of markets, and especially those who are minded to look under rocks for problems, the disconnect between the economy and the market can be pretty discombobulating. “Why are stocks up, have you not seen how bad things are out there!?”


Although the man and the dog can take wildly different routes along the way - they end up in broadly the same place eventually.


And in the same way, although stock markets can take a very different road to the broad economy - they end up moving in the same direction over long time periods. Stocks mostly go up, because the economy mostly grows and corporate earnings mostly go up - that’s all you need to know really.


And the reason the economy grows over time, is because we are all incentivised to keep our collective shoulder to the wheel and make things better tomorrow rather than worse.


Past performance is not indicative of future returns. None of the above is intended to represent advice to any individual. If you have questions regarding your individual situation, please consult with a regulated financial adviser.

 
 
 

Comments


Contact us:

Leave us a message below and we will get back to you shortly.

Beechgrove Financial Planning

Beechgrove Financial Planning Limited is a Trading Style of Sylva Financial Planning Limited (authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority - FCA No. 523565, Registered in England & Wales No 07165472). Registered Office: Wing 1, 9th Floor Berkeley Square House, Berkeley Square, London, England, W1J 6BY. The FCA does not regulate taxation, trust or legal advice.

This website is intended for investors over 18 years of age who are resident in the UK only. The website and the information contained therein should not be regarded as an offer or solicitation to conduct investment business in any jurisdiction other than the UK. The information on this page is not personal advice. Tax limits and rules can change, and their benefits depend on your circumstances.

Investments can go down as well as up in value, so you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

bottom of page